If you for some reason have not turned on ESPN this week, or listened to any sports talk radio, here is the situation: Kobe Bryant, after receiving a technical foul early in Tuesday’s game against the San Antonio Spurs, was caught on TNT, broadcast to a national audience, calling a referee a “f*&$king f*&$got”.
Unfortunately I feel a lot of bloggers and tweeters have turned this incident into an excuse for being self-righteous, and acting like Kobe murdered their favorite puppy. I’ve seen a few writers demand an apology from Kobe, as if he owes them a damn thing. And, as usual, this seems to have fallen along the usual “Kobe Hater” and “Kobe Fan” lines – if you already dislike Kobe, you probably went bananas over this situation. If you are a fan of Kobe or the Lakers, you probably thought it was no big deal. I initially fell on the “not such a big deal” side, but after thinking about it for the last few days, I have come to understand why his behavior demanded such a negative response.
First, I suggest reading this post from Yago Colas, which is so far the best view of the situation I have read. http://yagoc.blogspot.com/2011/04/cultures-of-basketball-course-diary_15.html .
First things first: Kobe should not have said what he said. It is simply not acceptable, on multiple levels. I am going to list those, in no particular order:
1. As one human being to another. Ok, this is actually #1 in importance. I simply cannot imagine a situation in which it is acceptable for a grown man to refer to another grown man by that term. Notice I say “grown man”. I remember being in high school in the early 00’s. That term was thrown around left and right, and to be perfectly honest I used it more often then I like to admit. In high-school. Then I grew up.
We live in an era where people are supposed to be civilized. While I do not agree with everything the “Politically Correct” crowd loves to argue about – sometimes it feels like people just want to feel offended and self-righteous about things – the fact is all of us should have learned by now how to treat our fellow human beings with respect. If Kobe is guilty of anything, it is not having learned the Golden Rule. At 30+ years of age, having kids of his own, he should have by now.
2. The fact that this happened on national television, let’s be honest, is the driving force behind this being such a huge issue. If it was not shown on TV, and maybe some sideline reporter tweeted about it, chances are few would have paid attention beyond the basketball blogging community. TNT should have prevented the clip from being shown on television – however the blame ultimately lies with Kobe, as he has to control his own actions. At the time, Steve Kerr even told the camera crew to cut away, because those watching at home might not want to see what Kobe Bryant was about to say or do. TNT could have done this – all live events are held back on a 7-second delay, thanks to Janet Jackson and her “wardrobe malfunction” at the Super Bowl – but whether due to the fact that it was so sudden, or that they thought it would be good television, they left the cameras on long enough to catch the moment. Kobe did not help matters by slamming his fist into a defenseless folding chair. That was pretty riveting stuff as a fan, and watching it live I remember wanting to see what was going to happen next. As a Laker fan I dreaded another technical that would have kept Kobe out of the Lakers last game of the season, at Sacramento, which is turns out they needed him to win. On a human level I just find it hard to take my eyes away from somebody flipping out on live TV.
3. Which leads me to the next problem with this situation: Kobe has anger issues. Real, serious anger issues. To be fair, he is not the first pro athlete at the top of his game to be driven by anger (see Michael Jordan and Tiger Woods). Kobe’s anger is probably part of what has pushed him to be as good as he is, like it or not. Such anger, however, is not a good look on an adult, especially one who is respected as being at or near the best in his profession. To put it simply, we expect stars to act with dignity, to show composure in times of stress. Anger, especially the rage you could see in Kobe in those moments, often comes from a sense of feeling powerless or frustrated at one’s situation. We do not expect one of the NBA’s best players to be a victim to such feelings.
Perhaps Kobe’s age is making him so angry, the fact that he no longer makes the plays he used to make with ease. Or maybe it is the fact that the Lakers had fallen back into one of their slumps, those stretches they go through where Kobe seems to be the only player busting his ass on a consistent basis. If you were the only one of your coworkers who actually cared about getting your work done to the best of your abilities, every day, you might get a little frustrated too.
But while I rationalize Kobe’s anger, I am not trying to excuse it. A little anger is acceptable, even necessary, in sports, but strutting around like a petulant child is not. It hurts Kobe’s image and reputation, and it hurts his play on-court as well – how many times have we seen Kobe force up multiple poor shots in an attempt to one-up some no-name player who dares to guard him too tough? Sadly it might be too late in his career for Kobe to really change his anger issues, but at the very least he can try not to be defined by them.
4. Last, but certainly not least, is the impact of Kobe’s homsexual slur on actual homosexuals. To be honest, I initially did not see this side of the argument. Why would a random person be offended by what one man says to another in a moment of anger? Benny (the ref in question) is not gay. Kobe was not trying to be seen saying such things on national TV. Nor was he going out of his way to denigrate any homosexual person or group. He was just really angry at someone, and was trying to insult them in some way, and “fa**ot” was the first thing he could think of.
Therein lies the problem with a mentality many, if not most, American males are afflicted with: the most insulting thing we can think of to refer to each other in a moment of anger is often to call the other person a homosexual. Instead of what Kobe really meant to say: “Benny, you suck at your job”, or “Benny, you’re an idiot”, or “Benny I hate you for not doing what I say!”, Kobe fell back on calling him gay.
I don’t think Kobe is truly homophobic, in the sense that he hates gay people and thinks they are the scum of the Earth. After all, he did put together this photoshoot. The unfortunate fact is that many American males are trained from a young age to view “fa**ot” as the ultimate insult. How can those who are actually homosexual even begin to feel accepted or safe in such a climate of disrespect?
In the end, this incident might end up being a good thing. Kobe Bryant and the Lakers organization have committed to working with GLAAD to promote a message of non-bigotry. Whether this is for PR reasons or an actual desire to change, the message is getting out there.